| Platinum | Jimmy Chews [ Primo - Pizza ] |
| Gold | Cocelli Pizza |
| Silver | Paezano's Pizza |
| Bronze | Score Pizza |
| Top Pick | Barnstormer Brewing & Distilling Co. Brewpub Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Dino's 2 For 1 Pizza |
| Top Pick | Il Buco |
| Top Pick | Licious Italian Bakery Cafe |
| Top Pick | Pizzaiolo |
| Top Pick | Pizzeria Italia Restaurant |