| Platinum | Hind Quarter Meat Co. |
| Gold | Nonna's Cucina |
| Silver | Firehouse Subs |
| Bronze | Fox's Bakery & Deli |
| Top Pick | Burnett's Butcher |
| Top Pick | Lazy Tulip Cafe |
| Top Pick | Licious Italian Bakery Cafe |
| Top Pick | Mr.Sub |
| Top Pick | Philthy Phillys |
| Top Pick | Zio's Italian Comfort Food |