| Platinum | Scaddabush |
| Gold | Licious Italian Bakery Cafe |
| Silver | Malones Pint House |
| Bronze | Cocelli Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bayside Variety |
| Top Pick | East Side Mario's |
| Top Pick | Il Buco |
| Top Pick | Limoncello Bistro |
| Top Pick | The Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | Zio's Italian Comfort Food |